This e-mail was sent to firstname.lastname@example.org:
I recently had my Grindr profile’s text zapped. So far as I can tell, this was because something in the text was deemed “suggestive”. Not explicit or offensive or in violation of copyright. (Of course, since I don’t have a copy of the text that was there before, I can only go by my memory of how “suggestive” it may have been.)
We’ve become used to restrictions on imagery with social networking sites (gay and otherwise) — many won’t allow any naughty images in the publicly available pics (and especially not pics which depict actual sex), and some even require an identifiable face — so the similar restrictions you have had in place there do not bother me.
But now you’re limiting text? Really? And not even explicit text, but “suggestive” text? Double really?
I never like to tie things to malice or stupidity where there may be a rational reason. Is this something that was dictated by Apple or RIM in order to get in/stay in their app stores? Did you get purchased by Disney? Are you trying to back away from the market that made you popular for some reason? (Because let’s be honest: Grindr’s #1 use is chatting up prior to hooking up. Please don’t try to deny it.)
Limiting what people can say (or write) edges into the realm of censorship. And even though it may technically be your right to limit what we can do through your system, if this over-the-top limitation of content is your own choice and not something forced on you (er, “insisted upon”) by external partners, I can’t help but think it’s going to bite you. (Actually, it’s apt to bite you even if this is capitulation to external requirements.)
Here’s hoping you’ll be willing to reply to this in some understandable form, whether that’s a personal reply or a press release or a web page which addresses the issue in a generalized manner (and hopefully has guidelines for what is and is not “suggestive”).
(A URL to your existing Terms of Service isn’t going to do it, especially since it doesn’t have the same text as the app put out notifying me of the zapped text.)
Looking forward to hearing from you.
I was finally able to dig around in their website Terms and Forums to find this:
Apple places limits on what can be displayed in a public profile. This includes not only your picture, but also text. Even masked text is not allowed. This means all public profiles have to be G rated. (link)“Masked text” would refer to things like “f*ck” and “po**ers”.
So they are trying to pass the buck to Apple. But when Apple did their booting of boobie apps a year ago, here what they said:
We have decided to remove any overtly sexual content from the App Store (link)Here are the full Grindr profile guidelines, which specify:
• No sexually explicit or overly suggestive text.In others words, no, Apple doesn’t say it has to be G rated, just that it cannot be “overtly sexual”. Notice what has happened in part: they dropped the “T”, turning “overtly” (openly) into “overly” (excessively); by definition, suggestive text cannot be “overtly” sexual.
More to the point, though, they don’t (presumably won’t) define how much becomes “excessive”. But by use of the term “G rated” (which Apple apparently does not require), potentially anything (sexually) suggestive becomes “overly” suggestive.
We shall see, though. I’ve entered new profile text, referencing hanky colors instead of any spelled-out activity (previously, I said something about “put me on my knees”), so the suggestiveness should be more vague; you need specialized external knowledge to decipher things.
Wouldn’t that be a kick in the pants, if gay social networking apps running scared caused a resurgence of the hanky code, only in textual form rather than actual cloth-in-a-pocket?
(Hmm, “kick in the pants”. That would be dark blue with white boot print pattern, right? Teal blue with boot print for “kick in the balls”?)
(And yes, I know there are Apple haters out there who are going to try to lay the blame right back at Apple’s feet. Your belief is already noted; only comments with some substance beyond that tired tirade will be retained.)